Void

Void

19 karma

(1118 comments, 1172 posts)

This user hasn't shared any profile information

Posts by Void

Nintendo Sceptic’s Journey through Zelda+Switch [part 1]

1
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

As you may suspect from the title this may not be the usual song of praise to Nintendo & Zelda Breath of the Wild. Others have done far more and better than me in this respect, for example check out HaikuHunter’s fantastic Zelda review or his cool Switch review (with a great test!). If anything I come from a very different background and it seems with very different tastes/values than most reviewers of the game, if anything seeing all those fantastic youtube/IGN/GameSpot/IGN/metacritic reviews got me quite critical as I was comparing what I was seeing with other contemporary and past games. Many people respond by saying that the game should be taken into itself but I am a person who’s played games for >25 years and when looking at a new game I can’t just pretend a lot of the great advancements we’ve made in the field in the past 10+ years were not there and just act like this one game just invented all that or lives on it’s own. By that logic I’m convinced if i took a badly rated metacritic game and gave it to a person who’s never played a game they’d be blown away. So, I will be judging this Zelda in the context of all the other games in the recent years, in relation to those, and not at all in relation to other Zelda games (which I haven’t played), and as a person who just bought his first Nintendo console. The fact that I bought this console is a testament to the fact that it’s the first time I saw a possibly play-worthy Nintendo game after the Super Nintendo which I respect for the 90s which I only admired form a distance though and later via some emulation. But with Zelda Breath of the Wild, an open world, and a handheld which I think is more powerful than the aging Vita. This makes Zelda: Breath of the Wild the most expensive game I’ve ever bought, game + console reaching to about 400$. I’ll give my first impressions in bullet points.

Special note: I have to mention that again there’s going to be a lot of “relative context”, in that in some points I’ll not just be addressing the game but also all the praise of it in criticism to other games which I found totally unjustified and shaped my expectations and where I’m coming from (and why I payed so much pretty much for one game). I’ll mark these with * .

 

+, +  [Switch] feels like a nice solid construction

+, + [Switch] Quick and smooth start from unboxing to being right in the game

-, – [Switch] I was rather disappointed with the display quality, on a sunny day it was quite hard to play without going inside (which sort of beats the point). In particular that starting room I kept bumping into walls

– , – [Switch] very very very poor selection of games, never seen such a short list of games in a store, and for me it’s even worse so far Zelda is for me the only game … I can only hope that in the years to come some devs will take a risk and at least port some old titles for the platform.

+, +, + “switch”-ing from docked to portable mode feels awesome, still a miracle even after doing it dozens of times.

-, +, – [Switch] The controllers felt rather tiny, got used to them in the end but they still have signal problems when even slightly away from the TV and i reaaaly dislike the asymetric joystick combined with the (to me) strange button placements and uses which contradict my PC, ps3, ps4, xbox 360 and bit of Xone customs

And now moving onto Zelda tself:

+, +, +, + Looks fantastic on the tiny screen. Just amazing to be seeing such small things with such detail. On the small screen the cell shading did indeed have a charm of it’s own and helped with contrst videwing

-, –  in docked mode though things look pretty empty. The graphics feel ps3 level, sometimes even ps2 level. I definitely and strongly disagree with all those portraying it as a current-gen platform. It feels last-gen at best, sometimes worse, with bland washed out textures without character and very few objects in the world, mostly just rolling hills terrain.

+ but the smooth open world makes up for a lot

– the colors feel pretty washed out. Initially i thought maybe it’s the feeling of a sunny day, which i like, but then i remembered a lot of games which have sunny worlds and yet decent contrast which doesn’t feel like i’m playing things on an aged tv

+, +, + I enjoyed the feeling of exploring the world, the openness was I think a fantastic decision

* So many people have said this game is so different and revolutionary to other games that it allows you to go anywhere and just explore. I didn’t find this at all as different as other games of this type: the moment i strayed of the path to just go another direction I was hit 2x to go back 1) by cold weather i couldn’t resist 2) by the game reminding me that I’m supposed to do something and go somewhere, something which happens later in the game too. Also the game clearly expect you to get the basic powers before proceeding, with the initial area serving as training ground. This is a typical game trope, nothing wrong with that, but I do resent all the statements/reviews which made it seem like this is never done before revolutionary.

-, + The music i heard (unlike the selections above) felt mostly bland and generic, semi-generated, with some chords and sounds, with only the occasional memorable song. Again, nothing wrong with that, just not the aweeesome sountrack i was lead to expect.  Mostly the game gets away with ambiental sounds of the world. I have yet to find in it though super memorable songs that stick or blow away like I did in other games. To take one example I think the soundtrack isn’t as memorable/professional as the Witcher 3 one, and i didn’t particularly love the soundtrack there, just saying.

-, – the whole world feels very “for kids”, from world to story to everything. For some this might be a plus for me it’s a minus.

* people kept saying how different from other games and unique this game is, particularly how much better it is than the worn out formula of AC games… yet what’s one of the first things I did and patterns I learned in the game?!? You climb a tall tower to reveal/conquer a big map section. duuuuh

-, -, – really low budget feeling with NPC interactions, silly sounds instead of voiced over, a place where i feel the game feels decidedly 10 years+ ago

+ the animations however are pretty nice

– the stamina indicator is i think really badly designed, a circle straight on the character, at the very least it should have been on the edge of the screen if not subtle animations or some overall screen effect like most games do such feedback, they instead placed a 2d distracting animation exactly center screen

– the black & white loading screen felt really not fitting. Might’ve worked for a stylized game like Persona but here it just felt out of place. I would’ve much rather had scenes from the landscape or screenshots or something that was visually fitting (for example handle it like Oblivion did with those frames)

+, -, – while exploring the world was fun, like a mixture of Minecraft, Grow Up, Gothic & Oblivion, as soon as I went into the big village the game showed it’s shortcomings even more compared to other games in the past decade, with the silly sounds instead of dialogues it was barely better than Okami on the ps2, and no longer doing things but rather having interactions the game felt even more backward and underproduced. Couldn’t wait to get out of town.

+ the environment interactions are pretty nice, enemies dropping weapons and being surprised when you take them, flames making fields on fire, nice stuff. Nothing I hadn’t seen done much better in Farcry Primal, Farcry 3 & 4, but still it’s nice to have it there.

* the restriction of some areas via clothing keeps making me think of the much better experience i had with that in Farcry Primal

– didn’t really like the cooking mechanics. It could’ve been much simplified, just interacting with a fire should’ve put you in cooking mode, instead one has to go into inventory, click once, click again to select, and only then begins making a cooking selection. Unoptimized!

* I particularly resented how many reviewers started their Zelda review by criticizing Ubisoft games, and this for a game which I feel in most places does not live to the high standards raised by those games. For example they would often start by saying that those games feel like a colect-a-thlon, unlike Zelda, but this game also feels to me exactly like that. You go around picking up things, finding places, picking up more things. Nothing wrong with that, I just find incredibly untrue how they put it. Sure, there’s moments when you’re delighted in Zelda by finding something unique, but I’ve found even more unique and interesting corners in other games from Assasin’s Creed to Dying Light.

+ I liked the things the game took from Shadow of the Colossus, from the big open areas with sun to the stamina for climbing, great things!

* Again contrary to all the praises I’ve heard i feel the game does a lot of the rinse & repeat type activities, unlike all the praising reviews that said this game is so different than that. You find a shrine, you solve it, you do it again, you find a tower, you climb it… and so on… And here too i saw other games do this more originally and with more variety: take for example the Oblivion gates/dimensions: they felt totally ‘deja vu’ and repeat, just like the shrines, yet some of them had fully lovingly crafted worlds in there, with interesting unique back stories and *fully voiced* interesting characters. Or even in a smaller scale, the towers of Farcry: all the same, and yet with subtle variations and challenges in figuring them out, they were mini shrine puzzles in themselves that I’ve never heard anybody make a big deal of.

 

Well, that’s it for now. Been playing a lot of Zelda, will play more, these are some of my thoughts so far…

TO BE CONTINUED

gameSketch 358

3
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

A game of not of thrones but of ackers.

Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: 47Crows x12, Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x10, Jaco x98, Firefish x31, Pori x2, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.

Rise of the Tomb Raider – quick impressions

6
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

As the credits now roll here’s some random thoughts and memories:

+, +, + a couple of really beautiful environments

+, + great scripted moments

– I did get or almost get stuck a few times in the to me contrived puzzles, leading me to put the game away for a while

+, +, – the game made some attempts at a more philosophical story, with pretty interesting audio logs. Too bad they could only be listened to while doing nothing else

– that Lara has fantastic powers, can jump and fall from amazing heights, kills and takes bullets better than Rambo, all of that I found acceptable/necessary for gameplay, yet some other things I thought broke the plausibility, in particular her use of a bow to pull down great structures… it was one point where i rarely could suspend my disbelief. It was one thing to accept her superhuman strength, but other than that the game transmits the message of somewhat realistic physics and with that I kept thinking how implausible it was that an arrow (with infinite rope?) could grab onto a big structure so strongly, even if she was so strong.

+, + the story themes of ancient religions around immortal(s) and civilizations was quite interesting, reminded me in some ways of the movie The Man from Earth with it’s interesting story

+, +, – there were some interesting special puzzle locations, they felt however mostly forced. Still, some of the best content in the game was in some optional relic locations

-, +, although the game is largely linear it does make attempts at sections of openness, which is appreciated

+ decent soundtrack

+, + impressive graphics technology, and attention to visual detail in this sense (depth of field, blur, particles, lighting & shadows… overall quite impressive on multiple platforms

+ the main story was okay, not fantastic IMHO, but passable and it did manage to surprise a little with the mixture of the supernatural elements while still staying a Tomb Raider game

Overall I’d give the game a +2 on a -5 to 5 scale: a technically competent game with much appreciated experimentation into more openness, it was an enjoyment from the beginning to end, never so that I couldn’t put it down, but always good enough that I knew the next play session would be consistently high quality. A good game overall, with AAA production values everywhere.

GTA 5 references & easter eggs

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

I really love the one about the book written by the son of the hero of Red Dead Redemption. Sparks my imagination in interesting ways to think that his son did write that book… what a different life than his father.

gameSketch 357

2
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

A deep underwater mystery smudging the line between man and machine while questioning identity.

 
Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: 47Crows x12, Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x10, Jaco x97, Firefish x31, Pori x2, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.

gameSketch 356

7
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

To combat magical heresy an institution forms under your sword… or staff

 
 
Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: 47Crows x12, Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x10, Jaco x97, Firefish x30, Pori x2, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.

Quake 2 Legacy

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

A lot of awesome memories from that game. My Voodoo Rush, playing at 16-21fps, discovering my first game secret in a 3d world that made physical sense (before that i used to wish i would discover one, but they were somewhat weird, with invisible walls and such). In particular the soundtrack I think still shines today.

Song of da day: Katamari on the Swing

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

There’s something quite magical about this game’s soundtrack.

gameSketch 355

5
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

A cycle of cycles happens where the worms eating from the roots are burned in flames that make the ashes rise to feed the falme upon blessed rebirth

 
 
Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: 47Crows x12, Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x9, Jaco x97, Firefish x30, Pori x2, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.

Horizon Zero Dawn Artwork

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Guerilla Games seems to have just released these days their artists to show a lot of game artwork & assets presentation. If you want to feast your eyes, great artists. You can check out the cool sculpts, paintings, animations and more here: https://magazine.artstation.com/2017/05/guerrilla-games-horizon-dawn-art-blast/

Top New Mobile Games [April 2017]

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

The Tempest pirate/open water one seems impressive and tempting, reminding me of 15+ years ago exciting in the PC space, and similarly I’m happy to see Planescape Torment out, I might get it yet once more :P Amazing the thought of such games of exploring a world existing on mobile!

gameSketch 354

12
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Learning to fly has never been so much fun. Fly (or crash) like a bird!!!

Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x9, Jaco x97, Firefish x30, Pori x2, player347 x7, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.

Dead Island Book

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

 

I had no idea a book even existed until we accidentally saw one on the shelves of a small store while visiting a new town. Had to get it out of respect for the game though not expecting much from the book. It is however turning out so far slightly better than anticipated. It’s relatively close to the events of the game so no big surprises there, and of course it’s impossible for a book to do okay in comparison to a big game world, especially one which excelled not so much via storytelling as much as in the environmental attention to detail and environmental storytelling, the mixture of natural beauty & human turmoil, the stories inside that and the feeling of exploration and discovery.

Prince of Persia (cover humor)

0
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

I found this entertaining. Even ignoring the comedy I was shocked to be so impressed by the original artwork! Great style, great craftsmanship.

gameSketch 353

6
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

in the unknown wild
the hero without a voice
is sometimes breathless
[HaikuHunter]


Thanks to HaikHunter for another great proposal!

 
 
Usual rules: 3 tries per person. Winner gets to propose a gameSketch. x5 multiplier for first timers. Newcomers: you may ask for 3 freebies even if you didn’t yet guess anything. Outstanding credits: Ange, PettyX90 x7, 47Crows x7, Haikuhunter x9, Jaco x97, Firefish x30, Pori x2, player347 x7, Tarpo x5, player347 x9, Diana x6, Radu x45, VideoGamesAsArt x2 , thegazer x9, BiaHawks x7, rsocu x5, Teofil S. Awaiting scenes from you guys.
Void's RSS Feed
Go to Top